Good form lead scoring criteria describe facts a person could spot in the submission. “Injured in Arizona in an accident caused by someone else” works. “Serious about hiring a lawyer” doesn’t, because two reviewers will read the same message and disagree.
That rule matters most when you use AI, which applies your wording literally and at volume. The same criteria also work for a person reviewing leads by hand.
Why points models don’t fit most contact forms
Classic lead scoring adds points for job title, company size, budget, and email opens. That makes sense when you have a CRM full of B2B data.
A local law firm’s contact form might collect a name, an email, a phone number, and a message, so there’s nothing to attach points to. Nearly all the useful signal is in the message, and the question is simple: is this the kind of job or case the client wants?
For these forms, use disqualifying facts and a star scale instead of points.
The four parts of useful criteria
1. Who the client is. Name the business, the location, and what it sells. Keep it to a sentence.
2. What qualifies a lead. List the services, locations, and situations the client wants, as specifically as they’d describe them.
3. What disqualifies a lead. This is often the most useful section, because disqualifiers are easy to confirm. Ask the client which leads they complained about last month, and you’ll get most of the list.
4. How to handle uncertainty. Say what happens when a message is too short to judge. Without this rule, thin leads get rated inconsistently.
Rewrite anything that can’t be checked
Test each line by asking whether someone could point to the evidence in the submission:
| Hard to judge | Easy to judge |
|---|---|
| Serious buyers only | Asks for a quote, an inspection, or a start date |
| Decision makers | Says they own the home or the business |
| Good budget | Project is a full replacement, not a small repair |
| In our service area | Located in Maricopa or Pinal County, Arizona |
| Not a tire kicker | Doesn’t say they’re only researching or comparing prices for later |
If a rule depends on something the form never asks, the criteria can’t enforce it. The better fix is one extra question on the form. A “Do you own this property?” dropdown does more for a roofing client’s scoring than any wording change.
Define the star scale once
A shared scale keeps ratings comparable across forms and months:
| Stars | Meaning | Default verdict |
|---|---|---|
| 5 | Clear match on every requirement, with a request to act | Good |
| 4 | Clear match, with one minor detail unknown | Good |
| 3 | Possible match, but not enough information to confirm | Your decision |
| 2 | Probably outside what the client wants | Poor |
| 1 | Clearly disqualified, spam, or a sales pitch | Poor |
Three stars is the rating that matters most. If your client’s team would call a vague but plausible lead, count it as good. If those calls rarely go anywhere, count it as poor. Write the decision into the criteria.
Three templates to adapt
Replace everything in brackets. Each template fits within the 1,500-character limit for client context in LeadUp’s form lead scoring, and works just as well as a checklist for a human reviewer.
Personal injury law firm
[Firm name] is a personal injury law firm in [state].
GOOD LEAD: A person injured in [state] in a car, truck, or motorcycle accident, a slip and fall, or a dog bite caused by someone else, within the last [2] years.
Medical treatment or a hospital visit is a strong positive.
POOR LEAD: Says they were at fault. No injury, or property damage only. Accident outside [state]. Already has a lawyer on this case. Workers' comp, criminal, family, or immigration matter. Vendor, marketer, or job seeker.
RATING:
5 = Injured, someone else at fault, in [state], recent.
4 = Same, with one detail unclear.
3 = Possible case, but the message is too short to confirm. Count as [good/poor].
2 = Probably outside these case types.
1 = Clearly disqualified, spam, or a sales pitch.
Do not lower a rating for spelling, grammar, or writing style.
Roofing contractor
[Company name] is a residential roofing contractor serving [cities or counties].
GOOD LEAD: A homeowner in the service area who wants a roof replacement, a roof repair, or a storm damage inspection. An active leak, recent storm damage, or an insurance claim is a strong positive.
POOR LEAD: Outside the service area. Renter with no owner involved. Commercial building over [size]. Gutters, siding, or solar only. Looking for a job or offering a product or service.
RATING:
5 = Homeowner in the area, replacement or active damage, wants an inspection or a quote.
4 = Same, with one detail unclear, or a smaller repair job.
3 = Roofing request, but location or ownership is unknown. Count as [good/poor].
2 = Probably outside these services.
1 = Clearly disqualified, spam, or a sales pitch.
If no location is given, do not assume it is outside the area.
Do not lower a rating for spelling, grammar, or writing style.
Managed IT services (B2B)
[Company name] provides managed IT and cybersecurity services to businesses in [region].
GOOD LEAD: A business with roughly [10 to 200] employees that needs ongoing IT support, cybersecurity, or cloud migration, or wants to replace its current provider. A business email domain, a compliance requirement, or a stated deadline is a positive.
POOR LEAD: Home user or personal device repair. One-time fix with no ongoing need. Student or research request. Vendor, recruiter, or partnership pitch. Business outside [region] that needs on-site support.
RATING:
5 = Business in range with a clear ongoing need who asks for a call or a quote.
4 = Same, with company size or timing unclear.
3 = Business inquiry, but the need or size is unknown. Count as [good/poor].
2 = Probably a one-time or poor-fit request.
1 = Clearly disqualified, spam, or a sales pitch.
A personal email address alone is not a disqualifier for a small business.
Leave protected characteristics out of your criteria, including race, religion, age, gender, disability, and family status. Screening on them can create legal risk, and they rarely tell you anything about whether the job is a fit.
Calibrate against the client’s judgment
Don’t launch criteria you’ve only read through. A short test will catch most of the problems:
- Pull 30 recent submissions, including some that became customers and some that went nowhere.
- Have the client label each one good or poor without seeing any scores.
- Score the same 30 using your criteria.
- Review only the disagreements.
| Disagreement | What it usually means | What to change |
|---|---|---|
| You scored it good, the client said poor | A disqualifier is missing | Add the fact that ruled it out |
| You scored it poor, the client said good | A rule is too strict | Narrow the rule, or add an exception |
| The client’s own labels are inconsistent | The client’s definition isn’t settled | Talk it through before changing anything |
That last row comes up more than you’d expect, and it’s useful to catch. If the owner and the intake team disagree about what a good lead is, no scoring system can settle it for them.
Afterward, repeat a smaller review every month or so, and any time the client changes services, locations, or capacity. A roofer who stops doing repairs needs new criteria the same day.
Check the distribution
If nearly every lead scores as good, the score isn’t separating anything, and your criteria are probably too loose. If almost nothing does, either the criteria are too strict or the campaigns have a real traffic problem. Look at the submissions themselves to find out which.
Bottom line
Write criteria that a stranger could apply to a submission and reach the same answer as your client. Start with disqualifiers, decide how to treat three-star leads, and test against 30 real submissions before you rely on the result.
LeadUp’s form lead scoring applies criteria like these to every submission, with a separate context for each client and a written reason for each rating. You can also draft the context from the client’s website, then edit it using the rules above. Once the scores are reliable, here’s how to switch Smart Bidding over to them.
